Alan Twigg’s tribute to Rudolf Vrba

Rudolf Vrba, who escaped Auschwitz and co-authored a report saving 200,000 lives, remains unrecognized in Vancouver despite his significant historical impact. Alan Twigg (l.) seeks to change this.” FULL STORY


Ormsby #75: Before the flood

Jay Sherwood’s Ootsa Lake Odyssey tells the story of a German immigrant couple displaced by the construction of the Kenney Dam in central British Columbia in 1952.

January 20th, 2017

Else and George Seel at Ootsa Lake with their son, Rupert.

Through the eyes of mail-order bride Else Seel, who arrived in the community of Wistaria from Berlin in 1927, Sherwood describes life in this isolated region.

Ootsa Lake Odyssey: George and Else Seel — A Pioneer Life on the Headwaters of the Nechako Watershed

by Jay Sherwood

Halfmoon Bay: Caitlin Press, 2016.

$24.95 /  978-1-987915-21-1

Reviewed by Sage Birchwater


Ootsa Lake Odyssey: George and Else Seel — A Pioneer Life on the Headwaters of the Nechako Watershed chiefly describes the lives of George and Else Seel, who worked in the Nechako Watershed for decades until they were flooded out by the massive 90,000-hectare Nechako Reservoir.

Else was thirty-three years old when she responded to a magazine advertisement by George Seel, a German-Canadian trapper, prospector, and stonemason who had moved into the Upper Nechako country in 1914.


Around the beginning of the 1900s, settlers established four agrarian communities along the south-facing north shore of Ootsa Lake. Marilla was at the eastern end of the lake close to the portage trail to Cheslatta Lake; Ootsa Lake was the main community at the south end of the road from Burns Lake; Streatham was a small community twenty kilometres west of Ootsa Lake; and Wistaria was ten kilometres beyond there and about fifteen kilometres from the western end of the lake.

George and Else Seel

The settlers coexisted with the Cheslatta Dakelh and Wet’suwet’en families who occupied homesteads and remote hunting and trapping areas until the region was flooded in 1952 by the Nechako Reservoir.

George had come to North America from Bavaria in 1911, then disappeared into the backcountry west of Ootsa Lake with two Swedish prospectors to avoid being sent to an internment camp when Canada entered the First World War.

By the fall of 1926, George felt his mining claims might sustain him, so he placed an ad in German newspapers seeking a woman who might want to come to Canada and live at Ootsa Lake and be his wife.

Else Lübcke responded. She was working in the archives of a Berlin bank clipping newspaper articles when she came across George’s advertisement. Part of Berlin’s vibrant cultural life, Else actively was participating in the literary community as a writer with stories and poetry published since 1921. She was hoping to expand her experience beyond the bland humdrum of the nine-to-five routine.

George was thirty-nine years old when he met Else at a hotel near the Vancouver train station. Sherwood eavesdrops on Else’s diary entries to give the reader a front row seat at Else and George’s wedding the next day.

George and Else’s son, Rupert, along the Nechako Reservoir in 2015.

Her intimate writings convey her feelings and first impressions as they sailed up the mainland coast to Prince Rupert, took the train to Burns Lake, and finally arrived in isolated Wistaria.

Else’s articulate diaries allow the reader to empathize with the life of a new immigrant entering Canada and getting established in the rugged British Columbia backcountry.

The reader is immersed in the dreams, aspirations, sentimentalities, and frustrations of the new settler entering a way of life that had been difficult for her to imagine.

Sherwood presents the first years of Else and George’s life together in great detail. After nine months of marriage, Else noted in her diary that she had spent seven of those months alone because George was away trapping and prospecting so much.

“Sometimes I don’t see anybody for days. And still I am very happy and not so alone; always in the best company.”

Sherwood titles the chapter of their life together at the end of the Roaring Twenties as “Prosperity.” Else generated a small income by writing for German magazines about her rustic life in Canada, George’s mining efforts bore fruit, and their son (and future prospector) Rupert Seel was born in December 1928.

The remains of the Bob Nelson home in 2015. This building also served as the Wistaria post office, and the school teacherage was upstairs.

As with most people, the decade of the Great Depression was difficult for Else and George. In the chapter “Subsistence,” Sherwood describes the mental and physical hardships experienced by the Seel family as they lived hand-to-mouth and, more often than not, indebted to the local storeowner.

When Canada entered the Second World War, Else was cut off from family members in Germany, now an enemy territory convulsed by the rise of Hitler. She managed to find out news about her family, including her mother’s death, through a friend in New York before the United States entered the war.

Sherwood’s previous and invaluable four volumes documenting the life and photographic accomplishments of Frank Swannell, the noted B.C. Land Surveyor, lay the foundations for Ootsa Lake Odyssey.

In 1920, Swannell began surveying the headwaters of the Nechako watershed and hired George Seel on his trail-building crew for $3.50 per day. Sherwood includes several Swannell images in Ootsa Lake Odyssey.

Sherwood also digs up a July 29, 1930 Winnipeg Tribune article foreshadowing the proposed flooding of the upper Nechako. Two potential hydroelectric projects were identified for British Columbia. One scheme would have seen water diverted from Chilko Lake into the Homathko watershed, with several dams flooding the Tatlayoko and West Branch valleys. The other project involved the damming of the Nechako River to create a giant reservoir, with water being sent westward through a tunnel to Kemano on Gardner Channel.

The Kenny Dam was finally constructed on the Nechako Canyon in 1952, but George Seel never lived to see it. In the two decades before his death in 1950, he had found employment on various aspects of the project.

The Seel residence was in a shallow, windy bay along Ootsa Lake, so their house was located in the present-day reservoir about 400 metres from the shoreline.

The rising water of Ootsa Lake flooded out the four communities of Wistaria, Streatham, Marilla, and Ootsa Lake, and settlers were left to negotiate the best compensation package they could with Alcan (Aluminum Company of Canada) for their expropriated property. Eighty households were displaced, but residents who lived on the benchland above the lake received no compensation even though their communities were gutted.

The Alcan project, signed  before W.A.C. Bennett became premier, was the first large-scale hydroelectric project of the post-World War II era.

First Nations citizens living along Cheslatta Lake were only given two weeks to vacate their homes, fields, and traplines flooded by the project and were given minimal compensation by the federal government.

Historian Jay Sherwood amid the North Shore mountains.

Ootsa Lake Odyssey is a welcome story for readers interested in the history of settlement and working lives in the Nechako watershed, in German immigration to B.C., and in the destruction caused by post-war hydroelectric construction in W.A.C. Bennett era.

Through the lives of Else and George Seel, Jay Sherwood documents half a century of life and work at Ootsa Lake and on the upper Nechako drainage before the flooding that changed everything.


Sage Birchwater photo by Peter Stein.

As a long-time resident of the Chilcotin, Sage Birchwater has written several books about the area including Chiwid (New Star, 1995), the second volume in the Transmontanus series edited by Terry Glavin. Born in Victoria in 1948, Birchwater was involved with Cool Aid in Victoria, travelled throughout North America and has worked as a trapper, photographer, environmentalist educator and an oral history researcher. Sage Birchwater continues to make an enormous literary contribution to the Cariboo and Chilcotin, having served as the Chilcotin correspondent for two local papers for 14 years while raising his family south of Tatla Lake. He has also lived in Taklayoko, where he was a freelance writer and editor, and later Williams Lake where he was a staff writer for the Williams Lake Tribune until his retirement in March of 2009. His other books include Ulkatchot’en: The People of Ulkatcho (Ulkatcho: Cultural Curriculum Development Committee, 1991); Ulkatcho Stories of the Grease Trail: Anahim Lake Bella Coola, Quesnel Anahim Lake, B.C. (Ulkatcho Cultural Curriculum Development Committee, 1993); Ulkatcho Food + Medicine Plants (Ulkatcho Publishing, 1996); Williams Lake: Gateway to the Cariboo Chilcotin (2005). With photographer Stan Navratil; Gumption & Grit: Extraordinary Women of the Cariboo Chilcotin (Caitlin 2009). Editor, with Gloria Atamanenko, Pam Mahon and Karen Thompson; Double or Nothing: The Flying Fur Buyer of Anahim Lake (Caitlin 2010) with D’Arcy Christensen; The Legendary Betty Frank (Caitlin 2011), Fly over the Cariboo Chilcotin Coast (2012) with Chris Harris and Corky Williams: Cowboy Poet of the Cariboo Chilcotin (Caitlin 2013) and Chilcotin Chronicles (Caitlin 2017).


The Ormsby Review. More Readers. More Reviews. More Often.

Reviews Editor: Richard Mackie

Reviews Publisher: Alan Twigg

The Ormsby Review is hosted by Simon Fraser University.

BC BookWorld



BC BookAwards

The Literary Map of B.C.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • About Us

    BC BookLook is an independent website dedicated to continuously promoting the literary culture of British Columbia.