#1 Welcome to The Ormsby Review
Richard Mackie and BCBookLook are teaming up to provide a new vehicle for serious writing about B.C.
September 16th, 2016
The Ormsby Review will be named after Margaret Orsmby, the venerable historian who often met with Mackie for tea and talk during her retirement near Vernon.
Many estimable pre-internet figures are vanishing from public knowledge due to limited information about them on the internet. Who today in British Columbia has heard of F.W. Howay or W.K. Lamb? That’s just one of the reasons why editor Richard Mackie and I have named our new journal for reviews about B.C. history and literature after historian Margaret Ormsby.
Richard will consider submissions from both academics and non-academics.
With your curiosity and readership, we hope to build a boundless forum for serious book reviews and commentaries about B.C. society.
We begin with a brief memoir from Richard, in honour of the publication’s namesake.
“Tea with Margaret Ormsby in her living room,” he writes, “was always a memorable and formal occasion. From her comfortable armchair, her soft voice quavered like a kettle simmering on a back burner. Her sentences ended with a gentle wheeze, as though someone had suddenly let the air out of her. ”
– Alan Twigg, publisher
Visiting Chairman Margaret
I got to know Margaret Ormsby when I was a Master’s student in history at the University of Victoria. In those days she also happened to be a neighbour in the Coldstream Valley, near Vernon, of my cousin Paddy Mackie, who would often see her at local historical events and gatherings and at the Vernon Museum, where he volunteered.
At first my acquaintance was mostly literary: I knew her magnum opus, commissioned for the 1958 centennial and called simply British Columbia: A History (Macmillan 1958), as a largely political history of the province that had never been surpassed. I also owned her two most-recent books, A Pioneer Gentlewoman in British Columbia: The Recollections of Susan Allison (UBC Press 1976) and the Fort Victoria Letters 1846-1851 (Hudson’s Bay Record Society 1979).
This was back in the 1980s when Margaret was working on her history of Coldstream Valley, published in 1990 as Coldstream: Nulli Secundus by Friesen after being turned down by UBC Press.
I’m ashamed to say that, even though Paddy talked about Margaret a lot, I hesitated to introduce myself for several years because a professor of mine at UVic, a quantitative historian, had once sneered at Ormsby’s British Columbia as “classic seat-of-your-pants history.”
Fortunately, as I got older, I learned to make up my own mind about books and people, and I discovered what many already knew: that her work was accurate, reliable, and often inspired. Eventually I asked Paddy if I might go and meet her. He picked up the phone and called her, chatted for a minute and then handed the phone to me.
She invited me over that afternoon for tea, which in Coldstream means 4 p.m.
Only one property separated the Mackies and Ormsbys, so I was soon at her house on the lakefront beside a fragment of what was once a large orchard. I walked up to the front door and knocked. A minute later the door flew open and an annoyed elderly woman appeared. She asked me sharply why I hadn’t used the side door, as she had requested. This was classic Margaret Ormsby. She had mistaken me for the gardener’s boy.
I introduced myself. Needless to say she was as mortified as I was alarmed. I was then about 26 years old, but to her I must have seemed younger. She was in her late 70s or early 80s. I called her Margaret, because that’s what Paddy did, and she seemed fine with being called by her first name. “Dr. Ormsby” seemed too formal.
Our meetings thereafter usually consisted of historical chat and tea. She wanted to know what was going on at UVic and who was writing what. She told me how, in the 1950s, she had been given a private desk in the stacks of the BC Archives and how upset she was that this arrangement had never been renewed. Her network extended to one of my professors, Patricia Roy, who had been her student at UBC. I could see that Margaret missed the collegiality and the chinwag that active historians enjoy so much.
A year or two later I transferred to UBC to begin my Ph.D in history and geography, and again she wanted to know the news of old students like Cole Harris and Keith Ralston, and of ex-colleagues like Margaret Prang. She wanted to know who was working on the colonial era, or who was doing B.C. political history, and so on. I never mentioned the nickname for her that had arisen during her long tenure as head of the UBC history department. Her middle name was Anchoretta and somehow that led to her being referred to mischievously as Chairman Mao.
Visiting Margaret became part of my Coldstream routine. Once, when I was a doctoral student, I found myself telling her about my troubles with a certain member of my committee at UBC — a narrow, dogmatic, and insecure scholar who punished students for not doing things exactly his way. Margaret listened carefully and at the end said “Such a shame! Doing a PhD is quite hard enough on its own without having to deal with nonsense like that.”
“For tea, she always served pieces of buttered toast cut in half diagonally. I found this a pleasant but somewhat puzzling habit until, some years later, in a novel by Anthony Trollope I found a reference to exactly the same combination of afternoon buttered toast and tea. I was a rough British Columbian. Her tea must have been a cultural artifact: toast and tea her Victorian parents’ ideal of mid-afternoon sustenance.
Once, she took me up to the large open attic room that served as her study. The walls were lined with books and multi-paned windows that looked down to the lake. It was a scholar’s den and I envied it. She took great pride in her large collection of the pottery of Axel Ebring, the Danish interwar craftsman known as “The Vernon Potter.” She told me that Ebring had collected certain rocks from the ranges around Vernon and ground them down to add to his glazes.
She often shared her early memories of my Coldstream cousins, the Mackie and Marle families, who ran a boys’ boarding school in the Valley. Once, as a girl, she was walking along in the snow on a bitterly cold day when my great aunt Grace Mackie came by in a sleigh and stopped beside her. Margaret was born in 1909, so this must have been during the First World War. Grace invited her up into the seat and shared her warm covering with her, which I recall was a buffalo robe. This simple act of kindness made a deep impression on Margaret. Indeed it was one of the first of many memorable things she told me.
I used to think I was the only historian who ever visited her house on Kalamalka Lake, but over the years I have met old students of “Dr. Ormsby” who also made annual pilgrimages. I am glad that I was not alone in appreciating this kindly, inspiring, enthusiastic, supportive, and amusing woman whose lifelong passion was the British Columbia past and the historical profession that studied it.
In 1996, Margaret Ormsby fell and broke her hip and was transferred to the Vernon Hospital. Paddy and I went to visit her there, one of us sitting on each side of her bed. We talked for ten minutes. I wanted to talk more but Paddy had another appointment, and I’ve always felt guilty that I couldn’t stay longer.
I remember how Margaret looked at me as I walked away, as though she hadn’t finished either. She died soon after.
Twenty years after her death, The Ormsby Review gives us a chance to continue our conversations about British Columbia.
— Richard Mackie
“British Columbians have always been literate, and they have always been inspired by a sense of their province’s destiny.” — Margaret Ormsby
Few other scholars have been so identified with the history of British Columbia as Margaret Ormsby. Published in 1958 to celebrate the B.C. Centennial, her British Columbia: A History was immediately a bestseller–at $4.75 per copy–and it remained the standard reference work for several decades prior to new histories by Martin Robin, George Woodcock and Jean Barman.
Born in Quesnel on June 7, 1909, Ormsby grew up on a Coldstream fruit ranch and attended high school in Vernon. Hers was one of the first graduate degrees conferred by the new UBC History department when she received her M.A. in 1931.
As a female academic, she was also a groundbreaker. She received her Ph.D from Bryn Mawr College in 1937, having earned a Bryn Mawr scholarship, but no positions were available in Canada. She taught at a private San Francisco high school until she could join McMaster University in 1940.
Ormsby overcame departmental discrimination against female scholars at both McMaster and UBC, where she began to teach in 1943. She finally attained the status of Full Professor in 1955. She became Acting Head in 1963, then chaired the department for ten years until her retirement in 1974.
Ormsby returned to live at the family home in Coldstream, continuing to write. Her local history of Coldstream, published when she was 81, boldly declared her hometown was ‘nulli secundus‘, second to none.
Along the way Ormsby became the second female president of the Canadian Historical Association in 1965. She chaired the Historical Sites and Monuments Board of Canada and the B.C. Heritage Advisory Board. She was a member of the Board of Governors at Okanagan College from 1980 to 1985. A Margaret Ormsby Doctoral Scholarship in B.C. History was established in 1993. There is a university-level Margaret Ormsby Prize for the Best Essay on British Columbia History.
Long active in the Okanagan Historical Society, Margaret Ormsby died in her Coldstream home on November 2, 1996 at age 87.
In 1993, a group of graduate students, assisted by the British Columbia Heritage Trust and other historically minded supporters, created the Margaret Ormsby Scholarship project. A fund for donations was established in support of scholarships which celebrate and recognize Dr. Ormsby’s contributions, ensuring that the work she pioneered continues. To this end, in 1997 the group officially established the charitable organization called The Society for the Promotion of B.C. History to help administer the fund in association with the Vancouver Foundation.
The lakefront house in which Margaret Ormsby was raised in Coldstream, and where she also resided in her retirement years, was demolished in 2014 after the extensive property had been listed for sale for $5.9 million and sold for an undisclosed sum that summer. Ormsby’s will had stipulated that the local district should have the first opportunity to purchase her property but the offer made by the town of Coldstream was refused.
Elected Freeman of the City of Vernon, 1959
Elected Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada, 1967
Order of British Columbia, 1990
Order of Canada, 1996
History of the Okanagan Valley. University of British Columbia, 1929.
Study of the Okanagan Valley of British Columbia. University of British Columbia, 1931.
Bibliography on the Okanagan District (pamphlet). B.C.L.A., 1935. — compiler
British Columbia: A History (Macmillan, 1959, revised 1971)
A Pioneer Gentlewoman in British Columbia: The Recollections of Susan Allison(UBC Press, 1976)
Coldstream – Nulli Secundus: A History of the Corporation of the District of Coldstream (Friesen Printers, 1990)
Dear Mr Mackie,
Page 11, BCBookworld, 209 John A Bosher, needs correction to John F Bosher.
Are you confusing BCBookLook with B.C. BookWorld (a newspaper)?
I read Margaret Ormsby’s book on the history of British Columbia several decades ago and found it fascinating. I found some photographs of her in the Vernon archives and use one of her as a May Day princess in 1921 in my lecture on the history of Camp Vernon.
Howard, I had no idea about her career as a May Day Princess! I will look it up. Thanks for the tip.
Thank you very much, Richard and Alan for introducing the venerable historian, Dr. M. Ormsby to me. I have read Dr. Ormsby\’s publications:British Columbia: A History, and A Pioneer Gentlewoman in British Columbia: The Recollections of Susan Allison and found them profound and given me much understanding of BC history. So very please to see the publication of The Ormsby Review. This journal might encourage historians, scholars and writers of other ethnic origins to share their history and heritage which have become an integral part of BC history.
Thanks, Lily. Margaret was one of many to toil in the sprawling vineyard — or should I say orchard — of the BC past, and help us to understand it.
Articles are not for sale.
I still have my copy of Ormsby’s BC History. So pleased that this woman historian – one of the first in Canada – is honoured. She not only cracked the glass ceiling for many, she broke ice to forge a path. Thanks to both of you for continuing the focus during this 150th celebratory year!
Hello, Betty! It is always good to hear from you. Dr. Ormsby did indeed break glass ceilings and icy paths… both in her career path in the 1930s and 40s and in those c-cold-Coldstream winters!
Twice in as many days I have come across your name. What a great idea to have this review. I have Margaret’s British Columbia – A History, but knew nothing about her. Thank you.
Good luck with this endeavour.
Hi Barbara, It is good to hear from you. Your estimation of Margaret Ormsby is most accurate. I think — I know! — she’d be tickled that we’ve done this. Keep in touch, Richard
The Ormsby Review is a great idea.
I have an article on Hermann Otto Tiedemann, architect of the “Birdcages”, which I would like to submit. How would you like to receive it — hard copy, USB stick, or . . .?
Hi Robert, sorry for the delay. I have been so busy. I know a little about Tiedemann and would like to know more. Please email me at firstname.lastname@example.org Thanks, Richard
Martin, I wish someone had a photo of Margaret being hoisted ashore! What an image. By the time I met her, in the mid 1980s, she seemed properly retired. Thanks for the recollection — and for the nice review of Glen Morford’s book.
The book reviews editor is Richard Mackie. The editorial coverage pertains to books related to British Columbia.
I served for some years on the British Columbia Heritage Advisory Board, as a cross appointment from the Board of the B.C. Heritage Trust. Margaret was a member of the former. Both boards made an effort to meet in locations around the Province. On a couple of occasions while meeting in the Okanagan we dropped by for tea. She was a great host and raconteur. However one of my best memories was a meeting in Prince George. We went out to visit the alleged original (archaeological) site of Fort George. This required a river trip in an open boat, from which we had to wade ashore. Margaret wasn’t to keen on that so two volunteers jointly hoisted her on their shoulders to make the ship-to-shore transfer. We were all greatly amused, but no one more so than her!
Hi Barbara, and many thanks. I hope you enjoy reading The Ormsby Review as much as I enjoy editing it! Yes, we are most interested in reviewing memoirs by B.C. people and our reviewers have reviewed nine published memoirs so far: see nos. 52 (McMullen), 50 (McCardell), 49 (Appleton), 47 (Dosanjh), 44 (Bowering), 43 (Smith), 38 (Sellars), 31 (McMillan), and 28 (Mair). Keep in touch. – Richard
I never met her, but burrowed into her British Columbia a History when doing my BA in History at the University of Victoria, and again when at Library School at UBC in the 1980s. I look forward to the Review, and I hope the genre of memoir will be well represented.
Like “citizen-scientists” in Biology, I believe “citizen-historians” make needed contributions to History through memoir.
Congratulations! What a welcome initiative deserving of great success.
Thanks, Chris! It is great to have your support. – Richard
This news is very exciting. I look forward to years of rich reading opportunities in The Ormsby Review.
Thank you, Lynne! We are working hard to make TOR a success. Between now and Christmas we will publish dozens of book reviews and articles, so please stay tuned.
Hi Jon, I agree. Her writing reached both academic and popular historians, both urban and rural, and it is still valued for its accuracy. Thanks for your support.
My first year in Honours History was the year Margaret Ormsby retired – my loss. Her early work with the Okanagan History Society is still of great value, and would her sense of scholarship still suffuse that Society! Best wishes to all associated with this new project.
Your recollections of visits to that fountain of learning and wisdom are wonderful.
I, too, have pleasant memories of this famed historian, especially from being in her History 426 Modern Canada class, arguably the finest undergraduate course on the History syllabus at UBC. A festschrift was published for her, a testament to the esteem held by her many fellow historians. I was pleased to be included. The Ormsby Review will continue the legacy, and thank you for launching it. Barry Gough
Hi Barry, You are the fourth friend of Margaret to send me your positive recollections of her work and teaching! (I could use them as the basis of another column). Of course I should have mentioned the fine festschrift, Personality and History in British Columbia. Essays in Honour of Margaret Ormsby, edited by John Norris and Margaret Prang (Vancouver: J.J. Douglas, 1977). Thanks for your memories.
Thank you, Richard. This is an exciting venture.
Thanks, Christine. It is indeed exciting — it is all happening very quickly and our articles so far have gone up in a day or two. Many book reviews are in the pipeline. Regards, Richard
This is a welcome addition to BC’s literary world. There is a great need to renew the conversation about BC’s history and cultures.
Hi Loys, the conversation is happening. It is a bit like an extended conversation at Margaret Ormsby’s house (she called it “Garafine,” by the way), and involving dozens or hundreds of people.
Excellent, Richard. This will be good for all BC historians, whether academics or trade book writers.
Hi Nancy, there does seem to be a real need for The Ormsby Review and the phone, or should I say the bell on my email, has been ringing off the hook.
Wonderful project. Can\\\’t wait to see it.
Hi Theresa, always good to hear from you. My brother and sister mention you from their Claremont days and I have been following your work. Keep in touch.
desperately needed to fill an immense chasm in literate BC history.
Hi Ron, it does indeed seem to fill a gap. What’s more, Alan Twigg works very quickly. We have having lots of fun too. Congrats on your two Haig-Brown/ Purdy articles.
Great to see this publication. I think it fills a much-needed niche.
Hi Mary Leah, thanks. It fills a niche and the response has been fantastic. I hope you can contribute!